Home Du-Mor Enterprizes, Action Utility Company, Inc., Du-Mor Drilling and Blasting

Du-Mor Enterprizes, Action Utility Company, Inc., Du-Mor Drilling and Blasting

Du-Mor Enterprizes, Action Utility Company, Inc., Du-Mor Drilling and Blasting

“SECRETARY OF LABOR,Complainant,v.DU-MOR ENTERPRISES, ACTION UTILITYCOMPANY, INC., DU-MOR DRILLING ANDBLASTING,Respondent.OSHRC Docket No. 83-0540_DECISION_Before: BUCKLEY, Chairman, and CLEARY, Commissioner.BY THE COMMISSION:This case is before the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commissionunder 29 U.S.C. ? 661(i), section 12(j) of the Occupational Safety andHealth Act of 1970, 29 U.S.C. ?? 651-678 (\”the Act\”). The Commission isan adjudicatory agency, independent of the Department of Labor and theOccupational Safety and Health Administration. It was established toresolve disputes arising out of enforcement actions brought. by theSecretary of Labor (\”Secretary\”) under the Act and has no regulatoryfunctions. See section 10(c) of the Act, 29 U.S.C. ? 659(c).Following an inspection by a compliance officer of the OccupationalSafety and Health Administration, a citation was issued to Du-MorEnterprises (\”Du-Mor\”) by the Secretary for a violation of 29 C.F.R. ?1926.21(b)(2).[[1]] The citation alleged as follows:The employer did not instruct each employee in the recognition andavoidance of unsafe condition[s] and the regulation[s] applicable to hiswork environment to control or eliminate any hazard[s] or other exposureto illness or injury:(a) Employees gauged trench depth walking immediately posing behindtrenching machines conveyer’ [sic] chain, exposing them to hazards ofrevolving chain, dislodged rocks and dirt.(b) Employees used trenching machines’ conveyer chain as means of egressfor trench, exposing them to hazards of unintentional movement of chain.(c) Trenching machine operator operated conveyer chain withoutdetermining that employees were not in proximity to hazardous movingparts of the machine.The citation was issued following an accident involving Kenneth Hampton,a laborer who had worked for Du-Mor for one week. At the time of theaccident, Du-Mor was using a Vermeer T-800 to dig a trench for a sewerand water line in Boerne, Texas. The machine excavated a ditch by usinga power driven conveyer chain extended vertically into the ditch. It wasconsidered an obvious danger by all of Du-Mor’s employees who testified.Immediately prior to the accident, Hampton was grading the trench, whichwas about four feet deep. This work consisted of picking up rocks thatthe Vermeer had left behind and moving them aside. The Vermeer’soperator, Ramos, disengaged the clutch, stopping the chain for a shorttime, although the engine continued to run. When Ramos started the chainagain, Hampton was pulled into the chain and killed. Ramos did not checkto see if anyone was near the digging chain before he restarted it.At the hearing, Robert Hargroder, Du-Mor’s general manager and partner,testified that it is Du-Mor’s policy to instruct its employees who areto be in trenches, to stay at least ten feet behind the digging chain onthe trenching machine and not to use the chain as a means of egress fromthe trench. He further explained that a ladder is used to get in and outof the trench when the trench is over four feet in depth and that themachine operators are instructed not to operate the digging chain on theVermeer without first ascertaining that no one is in proximity to it.Hanover, Du-Mor’s general superintendent, stated that he instructsemployees to stay about ten feet away from the conveyer chain and not touse the conveyer chain when getting in and out of the trench. BothRobert Hargroder and Hanover stated that they observed Hampton workingtoo close to the Vermeer and cautioned him to stay away from themachine. Troy Hargroder, Du-Mor’s foreman, testified that it is notDu-Mor’s policy to allow employees to walk immediately behind atrenching machine or to use the conveyer chain as a means of getting inand out of trenches. He and operator Ramos also spoke to Hampton aboutthe danger of working too close to the Vermeer.Du-Mor’s supervisors stated that a safety meeting is held once a month.The employees are paid a half-hour of overtime to attend the meeting andsign a receipt verifying their attendance. Each crew has its own safetymeetings. General safety regulations covering hazards the employees haveencountered or are likely to encounter, including the dangers of theVermeer, are discussed. The foremen are asked to pay particularattention to any new employees.Du-Mor’s laborers, Jamie and Rodriguez, had worked as laborers for oneweek prior to the fatality[[2]] and stated that they had not receivedany instructions from Du-Mor not to stand or walk immediately behind thedigging chain and not to get on the digging chain. Jamie admitted,however, that \”some other employees\” had discussed the need to stay awayfrom the chain with Hampton and himself, and he stated that he toldHampton to be careful. In addition he stated that Ramos told employeesto be careful when working near the Vermeer. Jamie and Rodriguezadmitted that they and other employees had used the chain to get into orout of the trench when the machine was shut off. Ramos guessed the chainwas used in this manner 5-10 times. Rodriguez testified that he knewthat using the digging chain when the machine was not operating wasimproper. Jamie stated that Troy Hargroder had seen the employees usethe chain, but Hargroder denied having observed such action. TheCompliance Officer stated he was told by Du-Mor’s employees that theywalked between two and ten feet behind the Vermeer. Rodriguez felt thatas a general rule employees walked from five to six feet behind themachine. There is no evidence that Du-Mor’s supervisors observed andpermitted employees this close to the machine.Judge Schwartz vacated the citation. He credited the testimony ofDu-Mor’s witnesses that instructions had been given and noted that theemployees were aware of the dangers of the machine. He did not, however,make any findings as to whether the employees violated the rules.The two Commission members are divided on whether the judge’s decisionshould be affirmed. Chairman Buckley would affirm the judge’s decision.He concludes that the standard imposes a single duty upon employers: toinstruct employees concerning hazards at the worksite. Dravo Engineers &Constructors, __OSAHRC __, 11 BNA OSHC 2010, 2011-12, 1984 CCH OSHD ?26,930 at pp. 34,507-34,508 (No. 81-748, 1984); Sawnee ElectricMembership Corp., 77 OSAHRC 24\/C10, 5 BNA OSHC 1059, 1060, 1977-78 CCHOSHD ? 21,560 at pp. 25,871-25,872 (No. 10277, 1977) (lead andconcurring opinions). In his opinion, the evidence establishes thatDu-Mor complied with this duty.The citation lists three separate instances in which Du-Mor failed togive instructions with respect to the Vermeer. The first two involve therequirement that Du-Mor’s employees stay a sufficient distance from thetrenching machine’s conveyer chain and not use the chain as a means ofegress from the trench. The evidence is conflicting as to whetherinstructions about the cited hazard were given. However, after,listening to the evidence, Judge Schwartz made a specific credibilityfinding that he was giving greater weight to the testimony of Du-Mor’ssupervisors that instructions were given. The judge explained thereasons for his finding and made it carefully and impartially in lightof the entire record. Accordingly Chairman Buckley would defer to thejudge’s evaluation of the credibility of the witnesses. See C. Kaufman,Inc., 78 OSAHRC 3\/C1, 6 BNA OSHC 1295, 1297, 1977-1978 CCH OSHD ? 22,481at p. 22,481 (No. 14249, 1978). He agrees with the judge that Du-Mor’semployees were instructed regarding the requirement not to walkimmediately behind the conveyer chain and not to use the chain as ameans of egress.The Secretary argues that even if instructions were given, they wereinadequate with respect to use of the conveyer chain to exit the trench.He relies in part upon the conversations Du-Mor’s supervisors had withHampton, noting that Hampton was not instructed regarding use of thechain as a means of egress. However, in these conversations, RobertHargroder explained to Hampton that he had lost his thumb on a smallchain of the ditching machine and that the larger chain would \”cut yourwhole head off.\” Hanover told Hampton he needed to stay away from themachine because the chain was very dangerous and \”there was no tellingwhat would happen.” According to Hanover, Hampton replied that heunderstood the danger involved. Both Troy Hargroder and Ramos alsocautioned Hampton about the dangers of the Vermeer. These instructionsgenerally warned of the danger of coming too close to the machine andwould indicate that it should not be used as a means of egress.Moreover, Hanover stated that he had instructed employees not to use themachine as a means of egress. Both Troy Hargroder and Hanover statedthat they had never seen employees exiting by way of the machine, andHampton was not observed doing that either. To the extent identified inthe record, the general warnings to him were precipitated by Hampton’sgetting too close to the Vermeer, and did not involve any use by him ofthe chain as an egress. It also is clear that the accident here wouldnot have occurred if Hampton had heeded the repeated warnings given tohim by both Robert and Troy Hargroder, Hanover, Ramos, and otheremployees. Chairman Buckley therefore concludes that the instructionsand warnings to Hampton were adequate.Chairman Buckley also rejects the Secretary’s argument that Du-Mor didnot instruct its employees that use of the chain as a means of egresswas prohibited when the machine was not operating. The evidence does notsupport a finding that Du-Mor’s instructions were inadequate to coverall instances of the chain’s use. Hargroder testified that it wasDu-Mor’s policy to instruct employees not to use the chain for egress,and that a ladder is used for that purpose when the trench is deeperthan four feet. Hanover testified that he instructs employees not to usethe conveyer when getting in and out of the trench. Thus, Du-Mor’s rulewas clear and unequivocal. Employees were instructed not to use thechain as a means of egress; there were no exceptions. Because thedangers from the chain’s operation were obvious, a general admonition tothe employees to stay away from the chain was sufficient. See ButlerLime & Cement Co. v. OSHRC, 658 F.2d 544, 548, 551-52 (7th Cir. 1981).As the testimony of Rodriguez demonstrates, he understood theinstructions to include use of the chain when it was not operating.In further support of its position that the citation should be affirmed,the Secretary asserts that the practice of using the chain as a means ofegress \”was not uncommon among employees.\” In making this statement, theSecretary is apparently arguing that a violation occurred because Du-Mor did not enforce its instructions. However, the duty to enforce isnot required by the standard, and Chairman Buckley would not rewrite thestandard to impose a duty not otherwise required. Dravo Engineers &Constructors, supra; cf. Bethlehem Steel Corp. v. OSHRC, 573 F.2d 157,161 (3rd Cir. 1978) (Commission should not strain the plain and naturalmeaning of words in a standard). In any event, the evidence does notsupport a finding that Du-Mor knew or reasonably should have known thatemployees used the chain as a means of egress. Although Jamie claimedthat Troy Hargroder saw such conduct, Troy Hargroder denied that he hadseen employees use the chain for egress and there is no other evidencethat Du-Mor supervisors observed any employees exiting by way of the chain.Du-Mor was cited in the third instance for failing to instruct thetrenching machine operator to determine whether employees are inproximity to the hazardous moving parts of the Vermeer before operatingthe conveyer chain. Robert Hargroder stated that it is Du-Mor’s policyto instruct the machine operators not to operate the digging chainwithout first looking to see that no one is in proximity to it. Thejudge credited Hargroder’s testimony. Ramos, the machine operator,testified that, he had discussed with Du-Mor’s supervisors the operationof the trenching machine when people are in the vicinity and also statedthat prior to the accident he had seen an operator’s manual and a safetymanual published by the Farm and Industrial Equipment Institute, whichdiscuss the requirement that all personnel must be at a safe distancebefore the operator begins operating the machine. Ramos also stated thathe knew better than to turn on the Vermeer when anyone was present andthat the dangers of the Vermeer had been discussed at safety meetings.This evidence unequivocally establishes that Ramos was well aware of thehazards of the Vermeer and of the actions he should take as the machineoperator. Accordingly, in light of the judge’s clear credibility findingand Ramos’s understanding as the machine operator, Chairman Buckleywould also vacate this portion of the citation.Commissioner Cleary would affirm the citation. He finds that theevidence establishes that some of the employees at the site were notinstructed as to the hazards associated with the Vermeer. AlthoughDu-Mor’s supervisors testified that they instructed employees concerningthe hazards of the Vermeer, the evidence is that they did not give suchinstructions to either Rodriguez or Jamie, who had been working aslaborers for only one week prior to the accident. Both men testifiedthey had received no instructions from Du-Mor not to stand or walkimmediately behind the digging chain and not to use the digging chain asa means of egress from the trench. Moreover Jamie was unaware thatsafety meetings were held. Rodriguez knew of the safety meetings butthere is no evidence that he attended any of these meetings. On thebasis of these facts, Commissioner Cleary finds that these employeeswere not adequately instructed about the hazards of the Vermeer. Anemployer does not fulfill his duty under the cited standard by waitingto give employees safety instructions after they are performing a jobrather than training them in advance to avoid hazards. See SawneeElectric Membership Corp., supra. (Cleary, dissenting).The record also fails to establish that Ramos was instructed todetermine that employees were not in proximity to the conveyer chainbefore operating it. As with the instructions to the laborers, none ofDu- Mor’s supervisors testified that they gave Ramos instructionsconcerning operation of the chain, and Ramos’ testimony is inconsistentas to whether he received instruction.[[3]] Du-Mor has not fulfilled itsduty under the standard because Ramos had seen two manuals discussingthe need to keep personnel at a safe distance before operating themachine. The record does not disclose whether Ramos read the manuals,and if he did read them whether he was instructed to do so by Du-Mor.The standard places responsibility on the employer to instruct itsemployees and this duty is not fulfilled if employees can coincidentallylearn of or recognize the hazards of the Vermeer. See generally Brown &Root, Inc., 80 OSAHRC 97\/A2, 8 BNA OSHC 2140, 2145, 1980 CCH OSHD ?24,853 (No. 76-1296, 1980) (final responsibility for compliance with theAct rests with the employer and cannot be shifted to employees).Commissioner Cleary also agrees with the Secretary that the instructionswere not adequate to keep the employees from using the chain as a meansof egress when the Vermeer was not in operation. Clearly, some of theemployees believed that it was safe to use the chain when the machinewas stopped. Rodriguez did not recall having received instructions thatit was improper to use the chain when the machine was off. Jamie saidthat he had not been instructed that such use was improper. Ramos statedthat he did not caution the employees when he saw them using the chainbecause the machine was off. As the Commission stated in New EnglandTelephone & Telegraph Co., 80 OSAHRC 54\/A2, 8 BNA OSHC 1478, 1490, 1980CCH OSHD ? 24,523 at p. 30,000 (No. 76- 3010, 1980), quoting Brennan v.Butler Lime and Cement Co., 520 F.2d 1101, 1018 (7th Cir. 1975), \”Rulesare more likely to be observed if their rationale is understood and itis made clear that they are not just arbitrary pronouncements but aregrounded in practical reasons of safety.\”But more importantly the evidence establishes that employees extensivelyused the machine as a means of egress from the trench, and that this wasdone over a period in the presence of a supervisor, Troy Hargroder. Thisis compelling evidence that the employees were not instructed to avoidthe Vermeer as a means of egress. Moreover, there was no ladder, and itwould appear the machine was the only means of getting out of thetrench. Additionally, Du-Mor violated the standard because it did notenforce the safety rules concerning the dangers of the Vermeer. The dutyto instruct includes the duty to enforce the instructions. See DravoEngineers & Constructors, supra (Cleary, dissenting); NationalIndustrial Constructors, Inc. v. OSHRC, 583 F.2d 1048 (8th Cir. 1978).The employer must undertake reasonable efforts to ensure that theinstructions are obeyed. If the employer does not do this, and employeesare free to ignore instructions, safety rules become a mockery.Commissioner Cleary accordingly would affirm the citation.Under section 12(f) of the Act, 29 C.F.R. ? 661(e), official action canbe taken by the Commission with the affirmative vote of at least twomembers. To resolve their impasse on the merits of the citation and topermit the parties to conclude this litigation, Chairman Buckley andCommissioner Cleary agree to vacate the direction for review. E.g.Texaco, Inc., 80 OSAHRC 74\/B1, 8 BNA OSHC 1758, 1980 CCH OSHD ? 24,634(Nos. 77-3040 & 77-3542, 1980). The judge’s decision concluding thatDu-Mor did not violate section 1926.21(b)(2) therefore becomes the finalorder of the Commission but is accorded the precedential value of anunreviewed judge’s decision.FOR THE COMMISSIONRay H. Darling, Jr.Executive SecretaryDATED: APR 26 1985————————————————————————FOOTNOTES:[[1]] 29 CFR ? 1926.21(b)(2) provides:The employer shall instruct each employee in the recognition andevidence of unsafe conditions and the regulations applicable to his workenvironment to control or eliminate any hazards or other exposure toillness or injury.[[2]] Rodriguez had been a truck driver for Du-Mor for over a yearprevious to working as a laborer.[[3]] At one point Ramos stated he had not received specificinstructions from Du-Mor not to operate the machine without checking tobe sure that anyone was near the digging chain. However, he alsotestified he had received instructions from Du-Mor’s supervisors aboutoperating the trenching machine when people are in the vicinity.”